Home

 

Learning disabilities no barrier to college
By Karen Thomas, USA TODAY

Imagine a brainstorm: colorful ideas chaotically careening through space, sometimes jettisoning off on a tangent, some crashing into each other, some overlapping.

Now capture it and splat it onto a piece of paper.

Welcome to Jonathan Mooney's academic experience. And we're not talking recreational drug use here; we're talking English lit.

Colored pencils are essentail tools in the writing process for Mooney, a senior at Brown University, just as quiet talks with his girlfriend are a - if not the - major component of reading comprehension.

Diagnosed with dyslexia at the elementary level, Mooney, 22, spells on a third-grade level and reads with the lowest 10% of the population.

Yet at the Ivy League school, he chose to major in English (against the advice of some less-than-confident professors) and has maintained a 4.0 grade-point average.

"The myth that learning-disabled students are somehow less intelligent and therefore less able to go to college, or to go to the Ivy Leagues, needs to be debunked," says Susan Pliner, an assistant dean at Brown and head of disability services at the Providence school.

Oh, did we mention that Mooney has a book contract with a major publishing house? And that his tutoring program, which matches learning-disabled students from Brown with elementary-age children with similar learning styles, may go national soon?

A better environment

Not long ago, most colleges would not give serious consideration to applicants with learning disabilities. (It's an umbrella term that refers to neurological blips that skew a person's ability to get, store, and/or spit back information.)

Today, students diagnosed with problems such as dyslexia and attention deficit disorder (ADD) face a college scene less stigmatized and much more promising than that of a generation ago.

"Colleges are much more understanding of the necessity of giving accommodations" for learning-disabled students, says Carol Loewith, president of the Independent Educational Consultants Association. "If a student has been successful in high school with extended time on tests or textbooks on tape, the colleges don't consider that an excuse any more. It's just the way the student gets information best."

Most campuses have built-in support for those with the learning style of typical students. For students with quirks in the way they hear, see or remember information, provisions such as tutors, note takers, readers and time-management coaches "level the playing field," Pliner says.

The overall percentage of freshmen reporting disabilities remained stable at 9% between 1991 and 1998. Students with learning disabilities were the fastest-growing group among those 9%, increasing from 25% to 41%.

And students with learning disabilites are proving to be worthy contenders, says Frank Sopper, dean of admissions at Landmark College, a two-year institution in Putney VT that specializes in teaching such students. "Colleges are starting to recognize that they always had students with learning disabilities or attention deficits, and those students have often been their best and brightest."

The key to success, experts agree, is for students to fully comprehend their disabilities so they can ask for and get the support necessary to compete.

Mooney is all for being "open and honest" in an application, but "it's not helpful to simply say on the application, ‘I have a learning disability,’" he says. Rather, discuss how "it is a struggle to grow up feeling different. There's a lot of power there. It wasn't ‘Oh, I have dyslexia.’ It was integrated into how I see it affecting my work and my academic goals."

Mooney, who did not disclose that he was learning-disabled when he applied to a California college right out of high school, made his dyslexia the primary focus of his application to Brown. But he fears that the national trend toward understanding students with learning disabilities will have a negative side, and he warns college-bound students not to fall into that trap.

"I worry that the consciousness is coming more in terms of sympathy - ‘Oh, this person has a hard time spelling’ - and is not embracing the differences." Students need to be clear in their discussions with admissions counselors, he says, with statements such as "‘I have strengths and weaknesses. This (spelling) is one of my profound weaknesses.’ That's a better understanding of it."

By the time a student interviews for college, he should know his diagnosis and how it affects him, Sopper says. Students need to know what support worked in high school.

They need to be aware of the "invisible network" that isn't documented in the almighty Permanent File: There are friends who share notes, classmates who discuss assignments and parents who make sure kids are placed with teachers open to alternative teaching practices. (Mooney's mother, to whom he dictated most of his high school papers, is among "a thousand readers" who Mooney says help point out errors.)

The many learning-disabled students who have been guarded from that painful self-knowledge dismay Sopper.

"There's a tremendous grieving process when you discover you have a learning disability. Parents and children go through anger, denial, bargaining - and parents don't want to expose their student to that," he says. "It's much healthier if students experience that early on, when parents can help them manage."

Tough transition

The transition to college is especially tough for learning-disabled students, and the freshman fall-apart phenomenon happens often because "they're 18 years old, and they don't want this label any more. They think they've gotten into Brown and they don't need services" such as getting lectures and textbooks on tape or using a laptop for an essay test.

At the start of classes, Brown students are armed with letters outlining their disabilities and what modifications may be necessary, as well as knowledge from a workshop on how to communicate successfully with faculty, "not in a stigmatizing, I'm-asking-for-something-special way," Pliner says.

She is among many experts who strongly encourage students to shop around to get detailed information about services supplied on campuses.

Though laws mandate that colleges provide tutors, note takers and untimed tests, glossy admissions brochures can paint an unrealistic picture. Large schools may tout a program, but research may reveal only four kids enrolled.

"Is is a program, or is it being taught by an old lady with an apron?" says Loewith, who says campus visits are a must for students with learning disabilities. That's the only way to learn that the well-respected, highly touted college-based learning center is actually a half-mile off campus.

"Students feel like second-class citizens," Loewith says.

Also making the process difficult: Students with learning disabilities often have parents with the same disabilities. "Parents think, ‘I remember this. This is so awful.’ I tell them to take a deep breath, read a lot and ask a lot of questions," Loewith says. "It really is getting better these days."


Resources for students with learning disabilities who are searching for the right college
Association on Higher Education and Disability
AHEAD.org
614-488-4972

National Center for Learning Disabilities
NCLD
212-545-7510 / 888-575-7373

HEATH Resource Center
HEATH.GWU.edu
202-939-9300 / 800-544-3284

At the bookstore:
Colleges With Programs for Students With Learning Disabilities (Charles T. Mangrum II and Stephen S. Strichart, Peterson's Guides, 1997)

The K&W Guide to Colleges for the Learning Disabled (Marybeth Kravets and Imy F. Wax, HarperPerennial, 1997)